Skip to main content

The banality of sin


Why is the world the way that it is? Why is there such hatred and violence? Why is there injustice and racism? The Bible’s answer to these kinds of questions is sin. The most common understanding of sin is that it is breaking God’s law. That is one way that the Bible describes what sin but not the only way that the Bible talks about sin. Read Judges 17:1-13

                This section of Judges is often ignored because everything up to this point has been really interesting. The book of Judges offers a brief history of Israel as they come into Canaan the Promised Land. The book also functions as an “apologetic” for the monarchy in general and David in particular. In the first 16 chapters of the book we have these fantastic stories. The people would slide into sin and when they did they soon became enslaved by some foreign power. The people would cry out to God to be rescued and saved. In response God would send a judge to save the people. A judge was a savior. In chapters 1-16 God sends a judge to save his people 12 times. Once the judge arrived they often called the people to repent of their ways and then lead in the liberation of the people from their oppressors. Some of the judges were people like Deborah a women warrior/general, Gideon and Samson. The first 16 chapters are full of these great dramatic stories. In chapters 17-21 the stories we are given are not as dramatic and there are no judges that come. There is no salvation that comes. We are left with two ending stories found in chapters 17-18 and the other 19-21.

                What is going on in Judges 17? If you are going to give this story a title is would be something like Mom, Micah and the Levite. First, you have Micah stealing from his mom. He takes her money and when he hears her utter a curse against the robber then he gives the money back. He is not very good or very bad. How good can you be to steal from your own mom? How bad can you be to give it back?

                Then his mom cheats on God. When she gets her money back she says I am going to give it all to the Lord. She says “I solemnly consecrate my silver to the Lord for my son to make an image overlaid with silver. I will give it back to you.” Yet when it comes time she only gives 200 shekels and uses that to makes two images out of silver. She takes her silver images and puts them in her son’s chapel where he worshiped God. This is in complete contradiction to everything in the 10 Commandments and the law. So far we have Micah cheating on his mom and mom cheating God.

                Then along comes a Levite. Well Micah and his mom decide that they are going to have their own shrine. During this time there was a Tabernacle. It was the place where you could go to worshiped God. There was a place that Micah and Mom could go to worship God. Yet they want their own worship place and they want their own ephod. When they see the Levite approaching Micah and his Mom think they have the opportunity to become legit. They could have their own genuine priest. Well Micah offers the Levite a sum of money, clothing and place to stay if he will be their family priest. The Levite agrees and all seems well.

                Except in chapter 18 a group of Danite men come along. They are trying to find a place to live. They tell the Levite to come with them and they will pay him more. The Levite priest agrees to the terms from the Danite men. As they leave they take the silver images that Micah and his mom have in their own personal worship center. Micah gives chase to the Danites demanding that they return his silver images and personal priest. The Danites tell him to go home or they will hurt Micah so he goes home. That is how the story ends. Then in chapters 19-21, at the end of the book of Judges, we are completely unprepared for what happens. There is a gang rape of a woman that leads to a civil war among the tribes of Israel. The civil war is so bad that whole villages are leveled. Men, women and babies are killed. In the midst of all this violence and injustice there is not a single judges to be found. No salvation. No hero to save the day. No rescue from God. What is going on?

                I am not the only one to point out that there are no judges to be found in chapters 17-21. Every other part of the book is about God’s salvation. Perhaps what the author is showing us and therefore God is showing us is what we look like without salvation. This is who we are in our natural state without God’s salvation. Right away Judges 17 shows us some things that might just surprise us. Current culture and many Christians have some stereotypes about what the Bible teaches about sin and evil. The story of Judges 17 goes right against all of it.

                What do you really think that sin does to you in its advanced state? Most people believe that most of us are kind regular people who make mistakes (sin) from time to time. When we think of people who are really bad or diabolically evil we place them into a different state then just regular people. Hannah Arendt attended the trial of Adolf Eichmann. Hannah Arendt had survived the Holocaust. Adolf Eichmann was the German officer in charge of all the logistics of transporting massive numbers of Jews (and others) to concentration camps where they would be murdered. Eichmann was put on trial in 1961 and Hannah Arendt was in attendance.

After observing Eichmann during the trial she wrote an essay called the Banality of evil. Banal is a word that means common. Arendt’s conclusion was that Eichmann was not a diabolical evil monster.  She observed that Eichmann was a boring little man who spoke in clichés. He had no insights into life and possessed little sense of humor. He was a run of the mill guy who desired to be important and desired to have people like him. She suggested that Eichmann was not a monster. Instead he was just like all the rest of us. He was boring, superficial and shallow. Arendt’s essay stirred up controversy. Opponents suggested that anyone who could do what Eichmann did is not like the rest of the human race.

Arendt got it partly right and partly wrong according to the Bible. She said that because Eichmann was shallow and common that it lead him to simply follow orders and do evil. The Bible says it is evil that leads you to be common. The most advanced characteristic of sin in the human heart is not to make us diabolical evil monsters but boring. CS Lewis said is this way: We think that evil is liberating but the real mark of hell is a sleepless unsmiling concentration upon the self. We must understand hell as a place where everyone is concerned about his or her own dignity. It the place where everyone has a grievance and where everyone lives in the deadly seriousness of envy and self-importance.[1]

What CS Lewis figured out and Hannah Arendt observed is what Judges 17 is attempting to tell us.  Sin makes you boring because all you are ever worry about is how you are doing. How you look. How things are affecting you. There is always an insistent grievance because you are always feeling sorry for yourself. Sin makes you mediocre. The most advanced state of sin is nothing more boring than the person who is all wrapped up in how they look. Sin makes you this very uninteresting, unprincipled, shallow and boring person. This story tells us that the first thing that sin does is not make you bad it makes you boring.

 This story in Judges 17 also tells us what sin leads us to do towards God. Most people would think that sin in an advanced state would turn a person into an atheist. In this story we are told that Micah’s mother dedicates two images made of silver to the Lord. Boy that is terrible idea. Is she unaware of the first commandment? Thou shall not worship any other gods. Why would she worship another god? The answer is that she is not worshiping another god.

There are plenty of gods named in the book of judges. The Canaanites had Baal and Ashura. The Philistines had Dagon. Micah’s mom does not say she is dedicating her images to Baal or Dagon. What she has done is not worship another god she is worshiping a reduced god. She has resized God and place Him into her images. This is a god that you can put in your purse. This is a god that you can take places with you. This is a god that is tame and manageable. This is the heart of sin. A little, manageable tame god will give you a little and manageable person. The point of the end of the book of Judges is that banal, common people consumed in the sin of a “sleepless concentration on self” makes you capable of terrible things eventually.

The essence of sin is when we reduce God to our level. Ps. 50: 21 brings up this issue: “These things you have done, and I have been silent; you thought that I was one like yourself. But now I rebuke you and lay the charge before you.”  We think God is like us and can be bought.  Many people come to church, they read their Bible, they drop some bad habits as a way to buy off God. If I am doing these good things that please God than surly he answer my prayers or fix my situation. We think God owes us something. Micah was so happy when he got a Levite to be his priest. He thought it was his chance to make what he was doing legit. Micah thought that he could buy God off by following certain rules. Highly religious people, who are sure that God has to be good to you and answer your prayers, all you have created a god that you can put in your pocket and pull out whenever you are in need. By the way there is nothing more boring than a smug self-righteous person. They are the worst because a little god makes little people.

We think God is like us because we think that God is no wiser then ourselves. Know why were are so freaked out all the time? Because things are not going right. We wonder why bad things happen because after all we believe in a God. We can’t think of a good reason that this or that has happened then we often conclude that there must not be one. If you believe that God is big enough to have caused events to occur then certainly God is big enough to have some reason that is beyond our understanding. There will never be freedom in your heart until you admit that God is unmeasurably, infinitely wiser than us all and we have absolutely no idea what he is up to.

The book of Judges ends by telling us the reason for all this happening is because there was no king. What the author is saying is that there is no savior. There was no hero to show up and set things right and save the day. Perhaps something better than a judge a king might save the day and set things right. Yet even the best of the kings fail. We need good king.

Throughout the Old Testament God says no any image being made of himself or any other god. Is God only an abstract idea? After all we humans want something that we can see, taste, touch and smell. Colossians 1:15 reads “The Son is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn over all creation.” God says you want something you can see?  Then let me give you someone who loves, weeps and eats with you. At the same time someone who is greater than you can image. Not smaller but greater. When you have a God that becomes small then you have a bigger God then you could ever imagine. Which by the way no other religion claims. A God who is big enough to come down to our size. When you have a God that can do that then you have a God that is your ultimate savior.


[1] CS Lewis The Screwtape Letters (New York MacMillan, 1961) p. ix

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Thoughts on The Widening of God's Mercy by Hays and Hays

When I heard about the book by Hays and Hays titled The Widening of God Mercy I was intrigued. I had read Richard Hays' book The Moral Vision of the New Testament in seminary, especially the chapter on homosexuality. I ended up adopting much, if not all, of Hays' position on homosexuality and often used his reasoning while serving as a church minister.  I have read other things that Richard Hays has written such as Reading Backwards: Figural Christology and the Fourfold Gospel Witness and found it beneficial to my understanding of Jesus and what it means to be a follower of Jesus. When it was suggested that Richard Hays might have changed his mind about what he wrote in  The Moral Vision of the New Testament  on homosexuality, I wanted to find out for myself.  My Context I spent over ten years doing youth ministry in the local church. I now know many adults who used to be teenagers in my youth group. Some of those adults are gay or lesbian. That means unbeknownst ...

The Power of Touch

Some folks like to hug, and others would rather eat glass than get a hug. Okay, maybe not eat glass but they aren’t into hugs. You know who you are! Wherever you might be on the hug me or don’t hug me spectrum our human bodies were designed for human contact to thrive.1,2 Physical touch like a hug or holding a person’s hand can reduce pain, lower cortisol levels, boost immune responses, and foster empathy. Physical touch can also have a positive impact on our emotional health as well. It is a powerful moment when you feel down, outcast, and excluded and someone acknowledges your humanity with a handshake, hug, or hand placed on your shoulder. The point is there is power in human touch that goes beyond what our eyes can see. Frederick Buechner in his book  Whistling in the Dark talks about the power of human touch when he writes:  I hear your words. I see your face. I smell the rain in your hair, the coffee on your breath. I am inside me experiencing you as you are inside you ...

Chaplains can do more than pray

Chaplains have been instrumental in helping companies navigate various changes and challenges by providing emotional, mental, and spiritual support to employees. Here are some examples: Crisis Management and Emotional Support: Chaplains provide critical support during crises, such as dealing with the aftermath of accidents or deaths. For instance, a chaplain was able to care for employees at a truck stop following a shooting incident, offering much-needed emotional support and maintaining contact with the affected manager. They also help employees cope with personal crises, such as marriage and parenting issues, financial challenges, and mental health concerns like stress and anxiety. This support allows employees to remain focused and productive at work. Improving Workplace Culture and Morale: Chaplains contribute to a positive workplace culture by showing that employee well-being is a priority. This can lead to lower turnover rates, increased job satisfaction, and higher productivit...